Big city: the renter ends up with more
A flat in Berlin for €700,000, through a broker at 3.57%. You could rent a comparable flat for €1,800 a month. You have €140,000 in equity. As the owner you pay €350 a month for building fees and upkeep.
| Purchase price | €700,000 |
|---|---|
| State | Berlin |
| Broker | 3.57% |
| Closing costs | €77,490 |
| Equity | €140,000 |
| Monthly rent excluding utilities | €1,800 |
| Owner costs per month | €350 |
| Assumptions, defaults in the calculator | |
| Interest rate | 3.7% |
| Repayment | 2.0% |
| Appreciation | 2.0% per year |
| Rent increase | 2.0% per year |
| Investment return | 5.0% per year |
| Period | 30 years |
Result
- Wealth as a buyer after 30 years
- €1,325,974Value of the flat minus remaining debt, plus invested savings
- Wealth as a renter after 30 years
- €1,506,490Equity and every saving, invested
- Difference, buyer minus renter
- −€180,516Renting is ahead
- Break-even
- not reachedNo break-even within 30 years
All values as a table (example A)
| Year | Buyer | Renter |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | €89,478 | €166,367 |
| 2 | €117,215 | €193,611 |
| 3 | €145,743 | €221,766 |
| 4 | €175,088 | €250,869 |
| 5 | €205,276 | €280,959 |
| 6 | €236,332 | €312,075 |
| 7 | €268,285 | €344,258 |
| 8 | €301,162 | €377,554 |
| 9 | €334,992 | €412,007 |
| 10 | €369,807 | €447,664 |
| 11 | €405,637 | €484,577 |
| 12 | €442,514 | €522,797 |
| 13 | €480,472 | €562,378 |
| 14 | €519,546 | €603,378 |
| 15 | €559,771 | €645,857 |
| 16 | €601,184 | €689,876 |
| 17 | €643,823 | €735,502 |
| 18 | €687,728 | €782,803 |
| 19 | €732,939 | €831,850 |
| 20 | €779,500 | €882,718 |
| 21 | €827,453 | €935,486 |
| 22 | €876,844 | €990,236 |
| 23 | €927,719 | €1,047,054 |
| 24 | €980,127 | €1,106,030 |
| 25 | €1,034,119 | €1,167,257 |
| 26 | €1,089,745 | €1,230,836 |
| 27 | €1,147,060 | €1,296,869 |
| 28 | €1,206,118 | €1,365,464 |
| 29 | €1,265,079 | €1,434,752 |
| 30 | €1,325,974 | €1,506,490 |
Verdict: After 30 years, renting is ahead by €180,516.
The yearly rent is only 3.1% of the purchase price. Against that stand €77,490 in closing costs, which are lost when you buy, and €350 a month in owner costs. The renter invests the equity and the monthly difference. After 30 years the renter has €1,506,490, the buyer €1,325,974. Buying never catches up with renting in this period.