Cashcolt

Rent or buy: when does buying pay off?

Compare your wealth as a buyer and as a renter, year by year. Whoever pays less invests the difference. You see whether and when buying pulls ahead.

Reviewed by Marc · Updated 22 Nov 2026Free, no account

The short version

  • It comes down to rent compared with price: at 3.1% yearly rent of the purchase price, renting wins in example A, at 5.3% buying wins in example B.
  • In example C, buying only pulls ahead in year 20. If you sell or move earlier, you are worse off as a buyer.
  • The calculation uses 2.0% appreciation and 5.0% return on the investment. Change both in the calculator, the result reacts strongly.
  • The calculator is free and needs no account.
01 / Calculator

Your comparison, calculated live

Change a value and wealth and break-even update at once. Example A is preset, a flat in a big city.

Buy
€
%
€
€
%
%
Rent
€
%
Assumptions
%
%
years
Wealth as a buyer after 30 years
€1,325,974Value of the flat minus remaining debt, plus invested savings
Wealth as a renter after 30 years
€1,506,490Equity and every saving, invested
Difference, buyer minus renter
−€180,516Renting is ahead
Break-even
not reachedNo break-even within 30 years

After 30 years, renting is ahead by €180,516: €1,506,490 against €1,325,974. Buying does not catch up with renting in this period.

    Create account

    With an account you can save your comparison. Free, 30 days of everything.

    02 / Examples

    Three worked examples

    Same interest, same repayment, same appreciation, same investment return. What changes is the price, the rent and the costs. Every calculation runs over the same period.

    Example ARenting wins

    Big city: the renter ends up with more

    A flat in Berlin for €700,000, through a broker at 3.57%. You could rent a comparable flat for €1,800 a month. You have €140,000 in equity. As the owner you pay €350 a month for building fees and upkeep.

    Inputs
    Purchase price€700,000
    StateBerlin
    Broker3.57%
    Closing costs€77,490
    Equity€140,000
    Monthly rent excluding utilities€1,800
    Owner costs per month€350
    Assumptions, defaults in the calculator
    Interest rate3.7%
    Repayment2.0%
    Appreciation2.0% per year
    Rent increase2.0% per year
    Investment return5.0% per year
    Period30 years

    Result

    Wealth as a buyer after 30 years
    €1,325,974Value of the flat minus remaining debt, plus invested savings
    Wealth as a renter after 30 years
    €1,506,490Equity and every saving, invested
    Difference, buyer minus renter
    −€180,516Renting is ahead
    Break-even
    not reachedNo break-even within 30 years
    Example A: wealth as a buyer and as a renter over the yearsBuyer: from €89,478 in year 1 to €1,325,974 in year 30. Renter: from €166,367 to €1,506,490.0€250k€500k€750k€1,000k€1,250k€1,500k€1,750k51015202530Rent€1,506,490Buy€1,325,974Example A: wealth as a buyer and as a renter over the yearsBuyer: from €89,478 in year 1 to €1,325,974 in year 30. Renter: from €166,367 to €1,506,490.0€250k€500k€750k€1,000k€1,250k€1,500k€1,750k51015202530Rent€1,506,490Buy€1,325,974
    All values as a table (example A)
    YearBuyerRenter
    1€89,478€166,367
    2€117,215€193,611
    3€145,743€221,766
    4€175,088€250,869
    5€205,276€280,959
    6€236,332€312,075
    7€268,285€344,258
    8€301,162€377,554
    9€334,992€412,007
    10€369,807€447,664
    11€405,637€484,577
    12€442,514€522,797
    13€480,472€562,378
    14€519,546€603,378
    15€559,771€645,857
    16€601,184€689,876
    17€643,823€735,502
    18€687,728€782,803
    19€732,939€831,850
    20€779,500€882,718
    21€827,453€935,486
    22€876,844€990,236
    23€927,719€1,047,054
    24€980,127€1,106,030
    25€1,034,119€1,167,257
    26€1,089,745€1,230,836
    27€1,147,060€1,296,869
    28€1,206,118€1,365,464
    29€1,265,079€1,434,752
    30€1,325,974€1,506,490

    Verdict: After 30 years, renting is ahead by €180,516.

    The yearly rent is only 3.1% of the purchase price. Against that stand €77,490 in closing costs, which are lost when you buy, and €350 a month in owner costs. The renter invests the equity and the monthly difference. After 30 years the renter has €1,506,490, the buyer €1,325,974. Buying never catches up with renting in this period.

    Example BBuying wins from year 4

    Small town: buying pays off early

    A flat in a small town in Nordrhein-Westfalen for €260,000, without a broker. You could rent a comparable flat for €1,150 a month. You have €52,000 in equity, owner costs are €200 a month.

    Inputs
    Purchase price€260,000
    StateNordrhein-Westfalen
    Brokerno broker
    Closing costs€20,800
    Equity€52,000
    Monthly rent excluding utilities€1,150
    Owner costs per month€200
    Assumptions, defaults in the calculator
    Interest rate3.7%
    Repayment2.0%
    Appreciation2.0% per year
    Rent increase2.0% per year
    Investment return5.0% per year
    Period30 years

    Result

    Wealth as a buyer after 30 years
    €647,044Value of the flat minus remaining debt, plus invested savings
    Wealth as a renter after 30 years
    €246,586Equity and every saving, invested
    Difference, buyer minus renter
    +€400,457Buying is ahead
    Break-even
    Year 4From here, buying is ahead
    Example B: wealth as a buyer and as a renter over the yearsBuyer: from €41,054 in year 1 to €647,044 in year 30. Renter: from €56,279 to €246,586.0€100k€200k€300k€400k€500k€600k€700k51015202530From year 4:buying is aheadRent€246,586Buy€647,044Example B: wealth as a buyer and as a renter over the yearsBuyer: from €41,054 in year 1 to €647,044 in year 30. Renter: from €56,279 to €246,586.0€100k€200k€300k€400k€500k€600k€700k51015202530From year 4:buying is aheadRent€246,586Buy€647,044
    All values as a table (example B)
    YearBuyerRenter
    1€41,054€56,279
    2€51,188€60,489
    3€61,609€64,623
    4€72,328€68,669
    5€83,352€72,618
    6€94,692€76,459
    7€106,459€80,281
    8€118,885€84,296
    9€132,002€88,510
    10€145,846€92,936
    11€160,453€97,583
    12€175,861€102,462
    13€192,110€107,585
    14€209,242€112,964
    15€227,301€118,612
    16€246,333€124,543
    17€266,386€130,770
    18€287,511€137,309
    19€309,761€144,174
    20€333,192€151,383
    21€357,863€158,952
    22€383,835€166,899
    23€411,171€175,244
    24€439,939€184,007
    25€470,211€193,207
    26€502,059€202,867
    27€535,562€213,011
    28€570,802€223,661
    29€607,892€234,844
    30€647,044€246,586

    Verdict: After 30 years, buying is ahead by €400,457.

    The yearly rent is 5.3% of the purchase price, so renting is expensive compared with the price. The buyer is ahead from year 4 and has €647,044 after 30 years against €246,586 for the renter. The assumptions are the same in every example, what makes the difference is the ratio of rent to price. Change appreciation and investment return in the calculator to see how robust the result is.

    Example CBreak-even in year 20

    Mid-sized city: buying needs about 20 years

    A flat in Nordrhein-Westfalen for €500,000, without a broker. You rent a comparable one for €1,410 a month. You have €100,000 in equity, owner costs are €300 a month.

    Inputs
    Purchase price€500,000
    StateNordrhein-Westfalen
    Brokerno broker
    Closing costs€40,000
    Equity€100,000
    Monthly rent excluding utilities€1,410
    Owner costs per month€300
    Assumptions, defaults in the calculator
    Interest rate3.7%
    Repayment2.0%
    Appreciation2.0% per year
    Rent increase2.0% per year
    Investment return5.0% per year
    Period30 years

    Result

    Wealth as a buyer after 30 years
    €951,161Value of the flat minus remaining debt, plus invested savings
    Wealth as a renter after 30 years
    €935,272Equity and every saving, invested
    Difference, buyer minus renter
    +€15,889Buying is ahead
    Break-even
    Year 20From here, buying is ahead
    Example C: wealth as a buyer and as a renter over the yearsBuyer: from €78,951 in year 1 to €951,161 in year 30. Renter: from €117,027 to €935,272.0€250k€500k€750k€1,000k51015202530From year 20:buying is aheadRent€935,272Buy€951,161Example C: wealth as a buyer and as a renter over the yearsBuyer: from €78,951 in year 1 to €951,161 in year 30. Renter: from €117,027 to €935,272.0€250k€500k€750k€1,000k51015202530From year 20:buying is aheadRent€935,272Buy€951,161
    All values as a table (example C)
    YearBuyerRenter
    1€78,951€117,027
    2€98,438€134,560
    3€118,480€152,616
    4€139,091€171,214
    5€160,292€190,376
    6€182,099€210,121
    7€204,533€230,471
    8€227,612€251,448
    9€251,357€273,077
    10€275,789€295,382
    11€300,930€318,389
    12€326,802€342,124
    13€353,429€366,616
    14€380,834€391,893
    15€409,042€417,987
    16€438,079€444,928
    17€467,972€472,751
    18€498,747€501,489
    19€530,434€531,180
    20€563,061€561,862
    21€596,660€593,573
    22€631,261€626,356
    23€666,896€660,253
    24€703,600€695,310
    25€741,408€731,574
    26€780,354€769,094
    27€820,477€807,923
    28€862,021€848,319
    29€905,476€890,735
    30€951,161€935,272

    Verdict: Buying only overtakes renting in year 20.

    Until year 19, renting is ahead, from year 20 buying is. After 30 years the buyer has €951,161, the renter €935,272, a difference of €15,889. At the break-even both are close together, so small changes in appreciation or investment return move the year a lot. If you sell or move before year 20, you are worse off as a buyer, and selling costs are not even included yet.

    03 / Methodology

    How Cashcolt calculates

    Two kinds of wealth over the same period. The full derivation is on the methodology page.

    1. Loan and closing costs

      The loan covers the purchase price and closing costs minus your equity. The closing costs follow from your state, with 1.5% for notary and land registry and your broker commission. Interest and repayment give the monthly instalment.

    2. Wealth as a buyer

      Value of the flat after appreciation, minus the remaining debt, plus whatever you invest when buying costs less per month than renting.

    3. Wealth as a renter

      Your equity, invested at the return you set, plus the monthly difference when renting is cheaper than buying. The rent rises every year by your percentage.

    4. Break-even

      The first year in which the buyer reaches the wealth of the renter. Without tax on the investment and without selling costs.

    Methodology in detail

    04 / Questions

    Frequently asked questions

    How does the comparison work?

    The buyer puts their equity into the flat, the renter invests the same money. Every month, whoever pays less invests the difference between the loan instalment plus owner costs and the rent. The wealth of both sides is compared at the end of each year.

    Which assumptions decide the result?

    Above all appreciation (here 2.0% a year), return on the investment (5.0%), rent increase (2.0%) and the loan interest rate (3.7%). One percentage point more return can flip the result. Change the values in the calculator and watch the break-even.

    What is not included?

    Tax on the returns of the investment and the cost of selling the flat are missing. Larger repairs only appear in the owner costs you set per month. The personal value of living in your own home is not priced either.

    When does buying make more sense?

    When the rent is high compared with the purchase price and you stay long. In example B, the yearly rent is 5.3% of the purchase price, in example A only 3.1%. The shorter you stay, the more the closing costs weigh.

    Does the result apply to a flat as an investment?

    No. The comparison is for a home you live in yourself. For a rented flat with taxes, depreciation and sale, use the property calculator.

    Author and date

    Keep going with your real numbers.

    With an account you save comparisons, calculate loan, budget and loan-to-value together and keep your properties in one place. 30 days free.